Why am I seeing this ad?

First Pioneer Insurance Agency / Joshua E. Matthews Insurance Agency, Inc.

Funeral Insurance, Insurance Agency

Upgrade this listing

Website | (919) 598-6800
2144 Page Rd Suite 106, Durham, NC 27703, USA

Opening Hours:
Monday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed


Area Served:
Within 4 miles (6.4km) of 2144 Page Rd Suite 106, Durham, NC 27703, USA
Get more exposure


Choosing the right insurance policy can be a daunting task even for a well informed consumer. Image if you have no idea what you're doing?

At First Pioneer Insurance, our main goal is to make the process as easy, educational, and enjoyable as possible, with personalized and authentic advice from an experienced agent, who goes to bat for customers, and does the right thing every day.

One of the biggest reasons you would want to use an independent agent like us, is we work and live in your community, so you're supporting local economy and small business.

You're never just a number at First Pioneer Insurance!

Google Rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars (15 total ratings)

D Bartlett
5 Star
Josh and his team were very easy to work with, listened to my insurance needs and offered cost effective suggestions. Auto insurance carrier offered by Josh was better insurance at about 1/2 the price I was paying. The home owners insurance was a little less than my current insurance, but included ID theft benefits and full replacement cost coverage, which was not part of my current policy. He also suggested a personal liability policy to cover where other policy limits left me vulnerable and a renters policy for my adult daughter who lives with me…did you know your home owners insurance doesn’t cover the personal property of children over 21 living at home? I would strongly recommend Josh for all your insurance needs!
Wednesday 9th June 2021
Micha Hamilton
5 Star
By far the best insurance agency in the area. I called and talked with 5 other agencies about my new business and Josh Matthews insurance is the only group that would take us. We have been with them for over 1 year now. They now take care of my home, auto, and life insurance as well. I love being able to pick up the phone and get my questions answered right away. Thanks JM Insurance team!
Tuesday 16th March 2021
NCFishCoastal HntrNC
4 Star
Joshua and his team are first class and are always willing to answer whatever questions you may have. He is professional and he was able to save me and my family a substantial amount of money with home and auto insurance. I highly recommend giving Josh a call for your insurance needs!! Erie Insurance is a great company to work with if you have issues... Give him a call today...
Wednesday 4th May 2016
Jason Parrish
5 Star
All the staff I have spoken to, or worked with over the years have always been very friendly, professional, and helpful. I am very thankful to have found Joshua E. Matthews Insurance Agency, Inc., as I could have not asked for a better insurance agency. I would recommend this team over any other group hands down!
Thursday 31st October 2019
Wade Perrigo
5 Star
Definitely give Josh a call. He saved me so much money. I never knew I was paying too much until he was referred to me when I was in the home-buying process. I now pay less for my car and home owners insurance COMBINED than I was paying for just my car insurance at progressive. I even have better deductibles. I ended up finding out what my girlfriend was paying for insurance and told her to give him a call. She saved over $400 a year!
Wednesday 16th February 2011